I’m going to let you in on a little secret. Over the years, we’ve had clients who’ve paid tens of thousands of dollars to have their data analyzed by outside firms. They’ve been presented with fancy reports and a shortlist of whom in their database are the best prospects for a bequest.

We’ve gone in afterwards and, with a few suggestions and a wee bit of guidance, have coached the charity’s staff on how to pull up their own list. The list they pull up is virtually identical to the fancypants one they paid tens of thousands of dollars for.

So, in this month’s tip, I’m going to guide you through pulling up your own list of prospects.

Your list will have four segments, and I’ll start with the segment that will lead to the highest number of expectancies.

1. The Misses

Pull up all donors who use the honorific “Miss.” Why? Well, for one thing, they’re likely women who never married, and research tells us that women who never married are more likely to leave a bequest than women who are married or widowed.

Women who use the honorific “Miss” are also more likely to be older women. Younger women usually go with “Ms.” And younger women aren’t as likely to be thinking about leaving a bequest to charity in their will.

2. The Monthlies

Your misses segment will be a small one, so let’s dig a little deeper. Now pull up all your active monthly donors. It doesn’t matter how long they’ve been monthly donors. What’s more important is that they’ve deepened their relationship to your charity and are more likely than your average donor to consider leaving you a bequest.

3. The Loyals

Like your monthly donors, those donors who have given to you for three or more consecutive years have indicated to you that they are more deeply committed to your cause. They’re sticking with you, and you’re probably one of their favourite charities.

4. The Majors

Donors whose last gift was $500 or more are also good bequest prospects. There’s a reason they’re last on the list, though. They’re less likely than the first three groups to be loyal to your cause (or in the right age group, like our misses). However, at the end of the day, they’re still more likely to be prospects for a bequest than groups of donors not listed here.

By the end of this exercise you’ll have a list of great bequest prospects. Start stewarding and cultivating them and you’ll find yourself polishing a few diamonds.

Bonus tips

We’ve conducted dozens of focus groups with donors and here are two bonus tips (directly from donors themselves):

  • Donors already know how to make a bequest. Instead, tell them why they should make that gift to your charity.
  • Always keep your cause front and centre. Donors give to the cause, not the organization.

This post was written by Leah Eustace, ACFRE, former Principal and Chief Idea Goddess at Good Works. It originally appeared at Hilborn: the leading provider of information to Canada’s nonprofit sector.